Thread #3251

air bags or air cylinder?

10 archived posts · 671 historical views

drifto808February 19, 2007
#43790

air bags or air cylinder?

what has a better ride to it??air bags or air cylinders. which one do you guys use most?
View original BBCode
what has a better ride to it??air bags or air cylinders. which one do you guys use most?
Yokotas13February 19, 2007
#43791
ive had both, i prefer the cylinders with acumulators
View original BBCode
ive had both, i prefer the cylinders with acumulators
viplifeFebruary 20, 2007
#44021
Yokotas13;43791 wrote:ive had both, i prefer the cylinders with acumulators


good observation.

the tricky part is dialing in how high/low to charge the nitro.

I've used bags more than cylinders.
Either can be just as "comfortable" with the right execution.

Both can be equally as BAD (ride quality wise) depending again, on the execution.
View original BBCode
[QUOTE=Yokotas13;43791]ive had both, i prefer the cylinders with acumulators[/QUOTE]

good observation.

the tricky part is dialing in how high/low to charge the nitro.

I've used bags more than cylinders.
Either can be just as "comfortable" with the right execution.

Both can be equally as BAD (ride quality wise) depending again, on the execution.
LexbubbaFebruary 20, 2007
#44040
I guess it really depends on pressure. My ucf20 rides very rough at over 150 and below 135. Usually i ride the front at 138-40 and the rear at 120-125. The struts are on the softest setting, being the closest ride to the stock.
View original BBCode
I guess it really depends on pressure. My ucf20 rides very rough at over 150 and below 135. Usually i ride the front at 138-40 and the rear at 120-125. The struts are on the softest setting, being the closest ride to the stock.
DominikFebruary 20, 2007
#44043
Do either give 'stiff' suspension, like say, coilovers? Or just uncomfortable in other ways?
View original BBCode
Do either give 'stiff' suspension, like say, coilovers? Or just uncomfortable in other ways?
evilwaysFebruary 20, 2007
#44049

bag versus strut

I've used both and installed both on many cars. I always recomend airbags over struts. If installed correctly they will ALWAYS ride better than strut because they require less pressure to work.

A lot also depends on quality of pressure switch, valves, compressors,etc. They all work together. Just my 2 cents
View original BBCode
I've used both and installed both on many cars. I always recomend airbags over struts. If installed correctly they will ALWAYS ride better than strut because they require less pressure to work. 

A lot also depends on quality of pressure switch, valves, compressors,etc. They all work together. Just my 2 cents
LexbubbaFebruary 20, 2007
#44051
Depending on the pressure. I get a more "Stiff" feeling at higher pressures and a more "soft" feeling at lower pressures. I have yet to adjust the dampening on the strut itself to see if it makes any difference.
View original BBCode
Depending on the pressure. I get a more "Stiff" feeling at higher pressures and a more "soft" feeling at lower pressures. I have yet to adjust the dampening on the strut itself to see if it makes any difference.
allstarFebruary 28, 2007
#45363
bag over strut.
View original BBCode
bag over strut.
Yokotas13February 28, 2007
#45391
Dominik;44043 wrote:Do either give 'stiff' suspension, like say, coilovers? Or just uncomfortable in other ways?


theoretically a bag on coilover would
but it would take some adjustments. like not allowing the bag full length to expand. so that it would get full and air pressure would build up in the bag faster to maek stiffer *spring* rates

it works on paper, and theory. But i have yet to test it out for real. i found out i couldnt due to clearances in my suspension geometry
View original BBCode
[QUOTE=Dominik;44043]Do either give 'stiff' suspension, like say, coilovers? Or just uncomfortable in other ways?[/QUOTE]

theoretically a bag on coilover would
but it would take some adjustments. like not allowing the bag full length to expand. so that it would get full and air pressure would build up in the bag faster to maek stiffer *spring* rates

it works on paper, and theory. But i have yet to test it out for real. i found out i couldnt due to clearances in my suspension geometry
viplifeFebruary 28, 2007
#45432
Yokotas13;45391 wrote:
it works on paper, and theory. But i have yet to test it out for real. i found out i couldnt due to clearances in my suspension geometry


ive done universal strut over bags on production (jic) coilovers on my old q. it worked well, except for the lack of clearance in the fender well, which seems to be a problem on the g50, but not other platforms...

others have done the same. maybe some of the old timers can chime in.


as for the ride, it rides much better than a cylinder w/out dampening (acc). im not sure if my assessment is a good one, since i always drove with as little air in them as possible. the only time i really inflated the bags was to get into the driveway.

here are some old pics, chicken skin for those that remember that far back...

Forum image

Forum image

Forum image

Forum image

Forum image
View original BBCode
[QUOTE=Yokotas13;45391]
it works on paper, and theory. But i have yet to test it out for real. i found out i couldnt due to clearances in my suspension geometry[/QUOTE]

ive done universal strut over bags on production (jic) coilovers on my old q.  it worked well, except for the lack of clearance in the fender well, which seems to be a problem on the g50, but not other platforms...

others have done the same.  maybe some of the old timers can chime in.


as for the ride, it rides much better than a cylinder w/out dampening (acc).  im not sure if my assessment is a good one, since i always drove with as little air in them as possible.  the only time i really inflated the bags was to get into the driveway.

here are some old pics, chicken skin for those that remember that far back...

[img]http://www.angrylife.com/temp/bags_01.jpg[/img]

[img]http://www.angrylife.com/temp/bags_02.jpg[/img]

[img]http://www.angrylife.com/temp/bags_03.jpg[/img]

[img]http://www.angrylife.com/temp/bags_04.jpg[/img]

[img]http://www.angrylife.com/temp/bags_05.jpg[/img]